Crises, stress and reduced well-being can be part of the doctoral research process. According to a recent study from Belgium, almost half of doctoral researchers report psychological problems. Initial studies on effects of the Corona pandemic in 2020 suggest that the mental health of doctoral candidates is, compared with other researchers, more negatively affected by it. This is due to more uncertainty of (future) employment, and the stronger potential for isolation in doctoral candidates (study from the UK).
There is a widespread expectation that working on a doctoral thesis must be difficult and stressful and that promising doctoral candidates must be able to "endure" this. In contrast to this, it will be made clear on these pages that there is support available to help cope with crises. There are strategies for going through this phase of life and career as productively and happily as possible. The information provided below is aimed at doctoral researchers, supervisors and anyone else who would like to find out more about well-being during the doctoral process. Below are options for preventing and coping with crises, there is information on how to recognize crises, information on the most important points of contact, helpful literature and materials, as well as contact details for peer exchange networks.
The authors of an interdisciplinary study in Belgium state:
a sizeable group of PhD students experience psychological distress or is at risk of having or developing a common psychiatric disorder. Most prevalent are feelings of being under constant strain, unhappiness and depression, sleeping problems due to worries, inability to overcome difficulties and not being able to enjoy day-to-day activities.
According to this and other research, the following factors can increase the risk of mental health problems:
- High workload
- Problems with the supervisors of the dissertation
- Uncertain future prospects inside and outside the academic job market
- Hierarchies and dependencies as defining elements of the scientific system
- Isolation, lack of peer networks
- Occurrence of discrimination and sexual harassment
- Challenges in the research process
- Troubles with financing the project
- Challenges in personal relationships, work-life balance
The following groups can be particularly exposed to the risk of psychological crises:
- Internationally mobile researchers (due to the familiarization with a new environment, funding, visa, new language environment, low contact with family and social networks)
- Isolated researchers (e.g. in remote research areas)
- Part-time researchers (due to isolation from a research community, financial hardship, work-life balance problems)
- Researchers with disabilities (if no appropriate support is available, if the environment contains barriers)
 Levencque, K. et al. (2017): Work organization and mental health problems in PhD students, Research Policy 46(4), 868-879.
Signals of poor mental well-being could be the more frequent occurrence of illnesses, an inexplicable frequency of headaches and digestive problems, as well as changes in sleeping habits (see information sheet from the Federal Association for Psychotherapy on burn-out). The following actions can be helpful in preventing and managing crises:
Optional action: Build & maintain supporting networks in a professional context (especially with peers & external mentors).
Potential: You notice that others also have burdens, learn about their coping strategies and can ask for help and offer help. You have access to external and independent, but experienced support who looks at your issues with fresh eyes.
Optional action: Find out how a counselling session at one of the contact points (see below) works. Obtain basic information about the contact points and their offers.
Potential: You gain familiarity with processes of support and can assess whether you could benefit from it and what might be useful in case of emergencies.
Optional action: Be aware of personal symptoms of overload and take countermeasures with what usually feels good (e.g. participating more intensely in social life, playing sports, practicing relaxation techniques).
Potential: You experience yourself as self-effective and integrated into a community.
Optional action: Think about which stabilizing factors and supporting organizations & people you can fall back on in a stressful situation.
Potential: You strengthen yourself through self-care. In the event of a stressful situation, you have access to continuous support through the coping process.
Optional action: Talk to trusted people in your personal environment about the stress.
Potential: This can be a relief. It could show that other people share the experience and they might offer coping techniques or empathy.
Checking in: Psychologist Desiree Dickerson reccommends some useful strategies to support others in the text "How do I support my group members`mental health and wellbeing right now? A cheat sheet for checking in".
Mentoring Programmes can help establish a professional network outside of your immediate workplace. The University of Graz offers, for example, a mentoring programme for female researchers as well as, until 2022, mentoring stays as part of the Arqus university alliance.
Offers by the University
Counselling for all staff members of the University of Graz
Working group for equality issues: Support in cases of bullying, sexual harassment, discrimination, ...
Advice & intervention by the worker’s council for scientific staff
Advice & service for compatibility of studies / work & family through unikid & unicare
Advice regarding dis/ability, mental health, and chronic illness through the Center for Integrated Studies
Central contact point
|Overview of Contact Points for psychological counselling of Plattform Psyche||Link|
Psychologische Studierendenberatung Graz
|Ombuds person of the Austrian Federal Ministry of Education, Science and Research||Link|
European Council of Doctoral Candidates and Junior Researchers Equality Working Group
|Help in case of conflicts at work by the Austrian Union for Public Service: Konflikt- und Mobbingberatung|
Peer networks are useful for your own research, for professional development and for maintaining your own well-being during the doctoral phase (and beyond).
There are a number of independent, self-organized networks with different focuses around the University of Graz and across Austria, as well as some networks within the university. The list below contains networks/groups that may be of interest to doctoral researchers at the University of Graz. It is based on careful research - however, no guarantee can be given for the accuracy of the information.
|Open Writing Group for Doctoral Candidates||Working on texts and motivating each other||Info|
|Feminist Mothering||Open discussion for everyone who is interested in feminist mother*hood and trying to practice it in all its diversity||Contact|
|Netzwerk Qualitative Forschung||Interdisciplinary platform for the exchange of qualitative research methods and their application||Homepage|
|IG Externe Lektor_innen und Freie Wissenschaftler_innen||Information and discussions on the situation of “freelance” scientists, focus on the Austrian scientific landscape||Homepage|
|Mailingliste fem@le-L||Information on feminist (and) women's research topics in this area largest and most relevant Austrian list||Contact|
|Mentoring- and Career-Programmes for Female Researchers||Professional Networking, organized by the Koordinationsstelle für Geschlechterstudien and Gleichstellung of Graz University||Infos|
|Var.Ges||Peer Counselling for people with variations of sex characteristics and/or their family members||Contact|
|DISTA||Network for people who research and work in the area of disability studies||Homepage|
|list is in progress||...more to follow!|
If you would like to set up a peer network yourself and need support with the organization (e.g. room search), please feel free to contact the DocService team.
Self-care during COVID-19 and everyday: Tips by academic coaches and experts
- Petra Boynton (2020): Being Well in Academia: Ways to Feel Stronger, Safer and More Connected, Routledge.
- Tyia Grange Isaacson: Mental Health Guidance for Graduate Students during COVID-19, 15.04.2020, in: The Professor is In (Blog von Karen L. Kelsky)
- Desiree Dickerson: "I wish I’d taken my mental health more seriously in grad school", 20.01.2020, in: Sciencemag.org
- Desiree Dickerson: Seven tips to manage your mental health and well-being during the COVID-19 outbreak, 26.03.2020, in: Nature.com
Handling rejections (papers, jobs,...) and criticism in Academia
- Book Series: Insider Guides to Success in Academia - Book Series - Routledge & CRC Press
- "Dealing With Rejection", Podcast by Karen L. Kelsky PhD (The Professor is In).
- Jaremka, Lisa M. et al. (2020): Common Academic Experiences No One Talks About: Repeated Rejection, Impostor Syndrome, and Burnout, In: Perspectives on Psychological Science Volume: 15 issue: 3, p. 519-543.
- Glass, R.L. (2000): A letter from the frustrated author of a journal paper, In: Journal of Systems and Software, volume 54, issue 1, p.1.
- Pages 103-104 in: Hames, I. (2007): Peer Review and Manuscript Management in Scientific Journals. Guidelines for Good Practice. Oxford: Blackwell.
Experiences as told by doctoral researchers (on crisis/-management)
- Birck, Angelika (2003): Laura promoviert. Eine Satire in sieben Aufzügen [289 Absätze]. Forum Qualitative Sozialforschung / Forum: Qualitative Social Research, Art. 17, http://nbn-resolving.de/urn:nbn:de:0114-fqs0302171.
- Blog „Café cum laude. dissertieren oder desertieren“: Texts in German on: Krisen während der Dissertation, the Hochstapler-Syndrom, Depression und Doktorat
Dealing with crisis and success in the research process
- Fiedler, W.; Hebecker, E. (2005): „Promotionskrisen und ihre Bewältigung - Empfehlungen zur zielführenden Planung und ergebnisorientierten Gestaltung des Promotionsverlaufs“. In: Berendt, B. et al. (Hg.): Neues Handbuch Hochschullehre, Berlin, Stuttgart, Berlin: DUZ Medienhaus, Raabe, S.1-16.
- Lerchenmueller, M. J. et al. (2019): Gender differences in how scientists present the importance of their research: observational study, BMJ 2019;367:l6573, doi: 10.1136/bmj.l6573, Link.
Online information platforms about well-being related issues
- Blog of IG LektorInnen und WissensarbeiterInnen: Information and university politics for freelancers: Link.
- Info and events about active fatherhood of Verein für Männer- und Geschlechterthemen Steiermark: Link.
- Information portal against sexual harassment on campus, with tips for action, real-life case examples, and materials, created by Leuphana University Luneburg: Link.
- Information for university members affected by discrimination, provided by Graz university: Link.
- Exercises by the University of Manchester: Where do you draw the line on bullying, harassment and discrimination?
- Portal against Homophobia, Information and Counselling on sexualities, relationships, gender identity by Graz counselling center Courage: Link.
- Webinar-Video about the Bystander Intervention initiative for safer campuses of University College Cork (UCC) School of Law.
Recent studies on mental health in academia/doctoral education
- Briedis, K. et al. (2020): Gesundheit als Gegenstand der Hochschulforschung: Erste Ergebnisse aus zwei DZHW-Studien mit Promovierenden und Promovierten, DZHW-Brief 02/2020, Link.
- Sverdlik, A., & Hall, N. C. (2020). Not just a phase: Exploring the role of doctoral program stage on motivation and well-being. Journal of Adult and Continuing Education. Vol. 26(1) 97–124. Link.
- Evans, T. M. et al. (2018): Evidence for a mental health crisis in graduate education, Nature Biotechnology 36, 282-284, Link.
- Levencque K. et al. (2017): Work organization and mental health problems in PhD students, Research Policy 46(4), 868-879, Link.
- Panger, G. et al. (2014): The Graduate Assembly of University of California, Berkeley Graduate Student Happiness and Well-Being Report 2014, Link.
- Reevy, G. M. & Deason, G. (2014): Predictors of depression, stress, and anxiety among non-tenure track faculty. Frontiers in Psychology 5, 701, Link.
- Janta, H. et al. (2014): Coping with loneliness: A netographic study of doctoral students. Journal of Further and Higher Education, 38(4), 553-71, Link.
Studies and reports on wellbeing-related issues at universities
- List (2017): Gender-Based Violence Against Female Students in European University Settings. In: International Annals of Criminology 55 (2), S. 172–188.
- Durbach/Grey (2018): Grounds for concern: an Australian perspective on responses to sexual assault and harassment in university settings. In: Sundari/Lewis (Hg.): Gender based violence in university communities. Policy, prevention and educational initiatives. Bristol: Policy Press, S. 83–104.
- Zabrodska/Kveton (2013): Prevalence and Forms of Workplace Bullying Among University Employees. In: Employee Responsibilities and Rights Journal 25 (2), S. 89–108.
Preventative efforts at universities
- Hochmuth, C. (6.6.2020): Was Mobbing in der Wissenschaft verhindert, In: Forschung und Lehre.
Office hours after appointment. Via Skype4Business/Phone, or on campus in the Besprechungsraum, Halbärthgasse 6, 1st floor (no elevator), or the Room 0062, UB-Gebäude, Universitätsplatz 3a, 2nd floor (wheelchair accessible).